30+ Best Indie Horror Movies of All Time [Reviewed for 2023]

Are you a horror fan seeking a truly unique and terrifying experience?

There are many remarkable indie flicks out there that challenge conventions and redefine the genre.

These cinematic masterpieces captivate audiences with their thrilling stories and unforgettable visuals, providing a fresh approach to storytelling while staying true to the essence of horror cinema.

In this article, we will delve into standout indie horror movies such as Stake Land, It Comes At Night, and It Follows.

We’ll also check out boundary-pushing indie horrors like Martyrs and Green Room, along with psychological thrillers such as Goodnight Mommy and period pieces like Bone Tomahawk.

As a horror writer and filmmaker myself, I know what it takes to create a scary, effective horror story. In fact, you can learn more about my debut feature film in the list below!

So go ahead, sit back, and prepare for an in-depth look at some of the best indie horror movies out there today!

What Are The Best Indie Horror Movies?

Standout Indie Horror Films

Let’s start with some standout indie horror films that have made waves in the industry.

Evil Dead 2 (1987): A Perfect Blend of Horror and Comedy

Improving upon the original in every way, Sam Raimi’s Evil Dead 2 deserves its place as a classic in horror movie canon.

Though the beats are similar, with Bruce Campbell’s Ash starting out as a hapless everyman transforming into a confident and capable hero, this sequel is more focused and engaging, with a real sense of tension and urgency.

The breakthrough use of humor adds an extra layer of entertainment value without detracting from the horror.

Stake Land (2010): A Dramatic Tone Without Becoming Overwrought

Stake Land, directed by Jim Mickle, is a post-apocalyptic vampire film that stands out from its contemporaries with its gritty atmosphere and character-driven narrative.

Martin embarks on a journey through an undead-infested landscape, guided by his wise companion Mister. Stake Land defies expectations by focusing more on human relationships and character development than typical bloodsucking action.

It Comes At Night (2017): Engaging Character-Driven Experience During a Zoom Séance

In It Comes At Night, director Trey Edward Shults creates an intimate portrait of fear and paranoia set against the backdrop of an unknown threat lurking outside their home.

This slow-burn psychological thriller focuses on two families who are forced to share living quarters after society collapses due to an unspecified pandemic event.

It Comes At Night‘s claustrophobic setting adds tension throughout the film as characters grapple with trust issues and agonizing choices amidst growing desperation.

It Follows (2014): Unforgettable Despite Polarizing Opinions

It Follows, directed by David Robert Mitchell, is a divisive film that has garnered both praise and criticism for its unique premise. The story revolves around Jay, a young woman who becomes the target of an unstoppable supernatural entity after a sexual encounter.

While some viewers find the concept of a supernatural STD too simplistic or even absurd, others appreciate its originality and atmospheric tension. Regardless of one’s opinion on It Follows, it remains an unforgettable entry in indie horror cinema.

Innovative Approaches to Classic Tropes

Breaking away from traditional tropes, these indie horror films present thought-provoking questions and inventive spins on familiar themes. They explore enigmatic epidemics, vampire lore, suburban horrors, and grindhouse classics with heart.

Pontypool (2008): An Epidemic Consuming People’s Minds

Pontypool is a unique take on the zombie genre that centers around an epidemic spreading through language itself.

This Canadian film follows a radio host as he uncovers the terrifying truth behind the mysterious events happening in his small town.

By focusing on psychological terror rather than gore or jump scares, Pontypool offers viewers an engaging experience unlike horror movies with a similar premise.

Cronos (1992): Guillermo del Toro’s Debut Feature Reimagines Vampire Lore

Famed director Guillermo del Toro‘s first film, Cronos, showcases his knack for storytelling by putting a fresh spin on classic vampire mythology.

The story revolves around an antique dealer who discovers a device that grants eternal life which comes at a terrible cost. Del Toro masterfully weaves together elements of body horror and dark fantasy while exploring themes of immortality and human nature.

PIN (1988): Fuses Suburban Dread with Body Horror

Directed by Sandor Stern, this film’s haunting visuals, remarkable performances, and thought-provoking subject matter revolve around a twisted relationship between two siblings and their life-sized medical dummy, Pin.

What sets Pin apart is its exploration of deeper themes such as mental illness, family dysfunction, and the consequences of isolation; creating an unsettling atmosphere that lingers long after the credits roll.

Terrifier 2 (2022): The Bloodiest of Sequels

Terrifier 2 cemented its instant cult following due to its excessive gore, visceral and realistic practical effects, and unforgettable characters.

David Howard Thornton’s unforgettable performance cements Art the Clown as one of the most memorable horror villains in recent memory. He brings a perfect combination of humor, terror, and sadism to the role, making him a cult favorite among horror fans.

Boundary-Pushing Indie Horrors

The indie horror genre has always been known for pushing boundaries and exploring themes that go beyond supernatural entities or grotesque body horrors. These films dare to venture into uncharted territories, leaving a lasting impact on audiences.

Martyrs (2008): Explores Disturbing New Territories in Horror Storytelling

Martyrs, directed by Pascal Laugier, follows the harrowing journey of a young woman seeking revenge on her childhood tormentors, only to uncover a twisted secret society obsessed with discovering the transcendental nature of pain and suffering.

This cult classic from French-Canadian filmmaker Pascal Laugier pushes the boundaries of horror, presenting an intense psychological thriller that probes into the depths of human endurance and suffering.

Bone Tomahawk (2015): Horror Meets Western in This Unique Blend

In S. Craig Zahler’s Bone Tomahawk, horror meets western for an unforgettably graphic cinematic experience.

When a group of cannibalistic cave dwellers kidnaps settlers from a small town called Bright Hope, four men embark on a dangerous rescue mission that quickly turns into an intense battle for survival.

The Kurt Russell-led movie effectively combines elements from both genres resulting in thrilling action sequences accompanied by bone-chilling horror.

Get Out (2017): Jordan Peele Breaks Barriers with this Influential Film

Jordan Peele made waves in the film industry when he transitioned from comedy to mainstream writer/director success with his groundbreaking work on Get Out.

The movie masterfully blends horror and social commentary as it follows a young African-American man who uncovers horrifying secrets while visiting his white girlfriend’s family estate.

This trailblazing work opened the door for other filmmakers to explore similar topics and pushed boundaries.

Hereditary (2018): Debut Feature Blends Emotional Weight with Effective Jump Scares

In Hereditary, director Ari Aster showcases an impressive array of storytelling skills by combining emotional depth with terrifying supernatural elements.

Starring Toni Collette and Alex Wolff as a mother and son in mourning as their family is terrorized by both inner and outside demons, Hereditary has been lauded as one of the most remarkable independent horror movies in recent times owing to its special mix of mental fear and frightening suspense.

Psychological Thrills & Chills

The indie horror genre is no stranger to psychological thrillers that keep audiences on the edge of their seats. These films delve into the human psyche, exploring complex emotions and dark themes while delivering spine-chilling scares.

Goodnight Mommy (2014): A Tale of Adaptation and Psychological Terror

Goodnight Mommy, directed by Veronika Franz and Severin Fiala, tells the story of two young brothers struggling to adapt when their mother returns home from facial surgery covered in bandages.

As they begin to question her true identity, paranoia sets in, leading them down a terrifying path filled with tension and suspense. This Austrian film deftly explores themes such as trust, family dynamics, isolation, and fear through its unsettling narrative.

Green Room (2015): Showcases a Deadly Twist on Party Culture

In Green Room, director Jeremy Saulnier takes viewers on a thrilling ride as a punk rock band that becomes trapped in a secluded venue, forced to confront a group of ruthless neo-Nazis.

The film’s strength lies in its realistic portrayal of violence and the palpable tension it creates, while also delving into themes such as survival, human brutality, and the dangers of extremist ideologies. With its claustrophobic atmosphere, unrelenting suspense, and raw performances by Anton Yelchin and Patrick Stewart, Green Room stands out as a powerful example of a contemporary indie horror-thriller.

Spree (2020): Fresh Take on the Slasher Genre

Spree, directed by Eugene Kotlyarenko, cleverly mixes comedy and horror in a modern take on the slasher genre and found footage.

Joe Keery stars as Kurt Kunkle, an aspiring social media influencer and ride-share driver, who embarks on a murderous rampage while live-streaming his exploits to gain followers.

The serial-killer film offers biting commentary on society’s obsession with online fame while delivering suspenseful thrills.

X (2020): Adult Film Gone Bad

Set in rural Texas, X follows a group of young filmmakers who inadvertently provoke the wrath of a demented elderly couple while shooting an adult film on their property.

The film, by acclaimed director Ti West, addresses themes such as obsession, generational conflict, and the consequences of trespassing both physical and moral boundaries through elements of suspense, gore, and dark humor.

Emerging Indie Horrors/Thrillers Amidst Challenges

Despite the COVID-19 pandemic slowing down film production, indie horror filmmakers have persevered and continued to create unique and captivating stories. In this section, we will discuss three standout films that emerged amidst these challenges.

Relic (2020): Combining Haunted Houses with Monstrous Frights

In Natalie Erika James’ directorial debut, Relic, viewers are presented with both haunted house chills and monster movie thrills as they follow the story of three generations of women dealing with their family’s dark past and the impact of dementia on their relationships.

The film expertly blends psychological terror with supernatural horror elements to create an unforgettable viewing experience that leaves audiences questioning what it means to be truly haunted.

Censor (2021): Delves Deep into Personal Struggles Amidst External Challenges

Censor, directed by Prano Bailey-Bond, explores one woman’s unraveling grip on reality within Britain’s Board of Film Classification during the 1980s “video nasty” era.

As she probes a frightful movie connected to her sibling’s vanishing, the main character is compelled to confront her own personal fears and the indistinct lines between actuality and imagination.

This psychological horror film offers a unique perspective on censorship while delivering spine-chilling scares.

Spin The Wheel (2023): A Unique Take on the Apocalypse

Co-directed by David Heacock and Neil Chase (yours truly), this film explore the lengths people will go to in order to save themselves, even if it means risking their lives – and eternal souls – to do it.

Taking place in real-time, Spin the Wheel revolves around a group of strangers playing Russian Roulette with the Devil in order to save the world as it ends around them.

As the tension ramps up to intolerable levels, what begins as an act of self-preservation for some, morphs into willingness to sacrifice for others in this game of no return.

Groundbreaking Indie Horror Films

The indie horror space has been thriving in recent years, delivering scares on an epic level with a small budget. These films have pushed the boundaries of storytelling and provided a platform for unique voices to explore various themes within the genre.

Night of the Living Dead (1968): A Benchmark Classic

Night of the Living Dead, directed by George A. Romero, is considered one of the most influential independent horror movies ever made.

Often copied, but never duplicated, this black-and-white film introduced audiences to a flesh-eating zombie apocalypse as social commentary on classism and race relations during a turbulent time period in American history – and becoming the benchmark for the genre in the process.

His House (2020): Survivor Guilt Turned Monstrous

In Remi Weekes’ directorial debut, His House, we follow a refugee couple from South Sudan who are haunted by their past while trying to adapt to a new life in England.

This chilling tale blends supernatural elements with real-life horrors faced by refugees around the world, as the protagonists face an unknown evil in addition to their own inner demons borne of their tragic journey.

Psycho Goreman (2020): Campy Creature-Feature Fun

Fans of campy sci-fi horror will love Steven Kostanski’s Psycho Goreman, which follows a young girl and her brother as they accidentally unleash an ancient alien overlord.

This creature feature provides a wealth of special effects, hilarity, death and gore that are sure to entertain devotees of the genre, while at the same time pull at heartstrings and teach a few lessons about the importance of family.

Funny Games (1997): Hostage Horror Reinvented

Austrian filmmaker Michael Haneke’s psychological thriller Funny Games explores the dark side of human nature as two sadistic men take a family hostage in their vacation home.

With fourth-wall breaks and a meta-twist, the film challenges the audience as a surrogate accomplice in the terrors inflicted on the victims, becoming so well-received that Haneke later directed an American remake starring Naomi Watts and Tim Roth.

The House of the Devil (2009): Retro Look with a Modern Feel

In Ti West’s slow-burning horror flick The House of the Devil,a college student takes on a seemingly innocuous babysitting gig at an isolated house, only to uncover something far more sinister.

The film pays homage to classic ’80s horror films by using vintage filmmaking techniques like shooting on 16mm film and emulating the styles of its predecessors, while managing to bring a fresh take on the genre.

The Invitation (2015): Secrets and Lies Repurposed

Karyn Kusama’s suspenseful thriller The Invitation invites viewers into an uncomfortable dinner party where dark secrets are revealed, tensions rise, and paranoia sets in.

As past traumas resurface, this chilling tale about a man accepting a seemingly-innocent dinner party invitation from his ex-wife keeps audiences guessing until its shocking conclusion.

Exploring Social Issues Through Horror

Indie horror films have a unique ability to tackle timely issues by providing social commentary amidst terrifying visuals. This approach allows filmmakers to explore complex themes while still delivering an engaging and thrilling experience for the audience.

Possessor (2020): Body Horror and Autonomy Through Terror

Brandon Cronenberg presents dystopian body-horror as he explores issues surrounding technology, surveillance, identity, and personal autonomy in this chilling tale.

Possessor follows an elite corporate assassin who uses brain-implant technology to inhabit other people’s bodies in order to execute high-profile targets.

The compelling narrative is elevated by a unique visual style, effectively capturing the disorienting and unsettling nature of the story while highlighting the ethical implications of invasive technology.

I Saw the Devil (2010): Exploring Revenge and Morality

In I Saw the Devil, South Korean director Kim Jee-woon presents a chilling tale of unchecked vengeance through themes of morality and justice.

When his fiancée becomes the latest victim of a brutal serial killer, an elite special agent embarks on an unrelenting pursuit filled with bloodshed and cruelty in order to exact retribution.

By blurring the lines between heroism and villainy, I Saw the Devil challenges audiences’ perceptions of right versus wrong and justice versus revenge.

Blood Quantum (2019): A Fresh Perspective in Zombie Storytelling

Blood Quantum, directed by Jeff Barnaby, is a First Nations-directed take on zombie lore where white people are transformed into flesh-eating monsters.

This innovative approach provides an intriguing commentary on colonialism and cultural identity while offering audiences a thrilling experience with its gruesome visuals and intense action sequences.

Blending Genres for Unique Experiences

Indie horror films often excel at blending genres to create unique and memorable experiences for viewers.

By combining elements from different film styles, these movies push the boundaries of storytelling and provide fresh takes on classic horror tropes. This approach not only keeps audiences engaged but also allows filmmakers to explore new themes and ideas within the genre.

Let the Right One In (2008): Vampire Romance Meets Coming-of-Age Drama

Let the Right One In, a Swedish film directed by Tomas Alfredson, is a prime example of how indie horrors can successfully blend genres.

The movie combines vampire romance with coming-of-age drama, as seen through the eyes of a solitary twelve-year-old boy and a mysterious vampiric girl, resulting in an atmospheric and haunting tale that resonates with audiences long after they’ve left the theater.

Dead Man’s Shoes (2004): Revenge Thriller with Horror Elements

In Dead Man’s Shoes, director Shane Meadows skillfully blends revenge thriller elements with dark horror undertones.

Paddy Considine stars as Richard, an ex-soldier seeking retribution against those who wronged his mentally disabled brother in his absence from military service.

As Richard hunts down each perpetrator one by one, Dead Man’s Shoes delves into themes such as guilt, redemption, and family bonds while maintaining its chilling atmosphere throughout.

Folklore-Inspired Indie Horror Films

Indie horror films often draw inspiration from folklore to create haunting tales that captivate audiences. These movies explore the rich history of folk stories and legends, weaving them into chilling narratives.

The Ritual (2017): Uncovering Folk Horror Roots

Directed by David Bruckner, The Ritual follows a group of old college friends who embark on a hiking trip in the Scandinavian wilderness, only to find themselves stalked by an ancient, malevolent entity.

Blending psychological terror with supernatural elements – an a thoroughly unique and terrifying monster – the supernatural horror film creates an atmosphere of dread as it delves into themes of grief, guilt, and the fragility of friendships.

Titane (2021): Tackling Societal Issues Through Chilling Narratives

In Titane, director Julia Ducournau tackles gender norms, toxic masculinity, and parenthood through an unsettling narrative about a woman with a titanium plate in her head who becomes involved with a grieving father searching for his lost son.

This Cannes Film Festival Palme d’Or winner combines body horror elements with thought-provoking themes to create an unforgettable cinematic experience that challenges societal expectations.

The Forest Of Lost Souls (2017): Grindhouse Meets Arthouse

The Forest Of Lost Souls tells the story of a young woman and an old man who meet in the titular forest – a fictional place in Portugal and loosely based on Aokigahara,the Japanese forest where some people go to commit suicide – to do themselves in.

As they venture further into the woods, it becomes increasingly clear that one of them has motives that are much more sinister than they appear.

Drawing on a mixture of Portuguese, Spanish, and Japanese folklore, The Forest Of Lost Souls offers a captivating mix of mystery and horror that will keep viewers enthralled.

Classic Indie Horrors That Continue to Captivate

Films like Saw and The Babadook showcase innovative storytelling techniques that keep viewers on edge, while in the 1600s New England-set The Witch, family dynamics are explored alongside supernatural elements as puritans struggle to survive in their secluded home.

Texas Chainsaw Massacre remains iconic for its skin-masked Leatherface picking off teens one by one, while the Sam Raimi-helmed Evil Dead series launched both him and Bruce Campbell into stardom through comedic hijinks within the genre.

The Void (2016): Exploring Grief

The Void is a Canadian horror film that delves deep into themes of grief, loss, and isolation. The story follows a small-town cop who discovers an eerie cult-like group lurking around his town after encountering strange occurrences at a local hospital.

With its Lovecraftian atmosphere, practical effects reminiscent of John Carpenter’s work, and emotional depth exploring how people cope with grief, The Void has become a modern indie horror classic.

The Crazies (1973 & 2010): A Classic Horror Remade for Modern Audiences

Originally released in 1973 by George A. Romero, The Crazies was remade in 2010 by director Breck Eisner as a modern take on this classic indie horror tale about a small town affected by an unknown toxin that turns its residents into violent killers.

With updated special effects and social commentary relevant to contemporary audiences, the remake pays homage to its predecessor while offering fresh perspectives on paranoia and government overreach and control.

Common Questions About Indie Horror Movies

What is the most successful independent horror film of all time?

The most successful independent horror films of all time are considered to be The Blair Witch Project (1999) and Paranormal Activity (2007). The first is the film that launched the found-footage craze, and was made on a budget of $60,000 while grossing over $248 million worldwide.

The latter was made on an even smaller budget of around $15,000 while grossing over $194 million worldwide, making them the highest-grossing indie films ever. The innovative marketing campaign and realistic approach for each film contributed to its respective success.

What is an indie horror movie?

An indie horror movie refers to a horror film that has been produced outside the major studio system, often with lower budgets and more creative freedom. These movies are typically financed by smaller production companies or through crowdfunding efforts, allowing filmmakers to explore unique ideas and storytelling techniques without mainstream constraints.

Which movie is #1 in the list of scariest horror movies ever according to Rotten Tomatoes?

Rotten Tomatoes’ list of scariest movies includes many classics; however, their top-rated choice for the scariest film ever made may vary depending on updates in ratings. As per their current list, Alfred Hitchcock’s Psycho (1960) holds a high position as one of the best-reviewed classic horrors, and is generally considered one of the greatest horror-thrillers of all time.

What is the number 1 horror movie ever made?

Determining which movie stands as the number 1 independent horror film can be subjective due to varying opinions among audiences and critics alike. However, some notable contenders include Stanley Kubrick’s The Shining (1980), William Friedkin’s The Exorcist (1974), George A. Romero’s Night Of The Living Dead (1968), and Alfred Hitchcock’s Psycho (1960).

Conclusion

From character-driven stories like It Comes At Night to thought-provoking zombie tropes in Pontypool, there are many unique approaches to the horror genre that set themselves apart from mainstream productions.

These boundary-pushing themes and genre-blending masterpieces demonstrate the power of independent filmmaking to challenge audience expectations and convey impactful messages through daring works, making each a must-see for any horror-lover.

Love movie lists? Check out these other great articles:

Top 10 Evil Dads in Horror Movies

Best Evil Horror Movie Mothers [Top 10 Scariest Moms]

Knock ‘Em Dead: The Top 10 Best Horror Western Movies